Mattress Topper Reviews, Ratings and Comparisons

Why Do You Need A Topper?

Just like pillows and mattress, quality toppers can also help to improve your sleeping comfort at night. A quality topper should breathe well, enhance sleeping comfort, and improve the overall performance of your mattress.

1. Prolong the service life of old mattresses

Our mattresses tend to lose much of its firmness, support, and comfort with everyday use. Instead of shopping for a new mattress which can be very pricey, a perfect mattress topper can largely revitalize your aging mattress at a comparatively small cost.

2. Improve the comfort of a new mattress

Apart from old mattresses, if you happen to buy a new mattress that does not have the ideal firmness, a topper can alter the comfort to suit your personal need.

3. Provide different firmness for each side

If you sleep with a partner who happens to have a very different comfort or support need from you, a mattress topper might be added to one side of the bed to provide different firmness levels for two sides.

Possible Downsides

1. Not always a "mattress saver"

Although a topper can revitalize an aging mattress by improving cushioning, problems like popping springs, serious sagging cannot be fixed by simply adding a topper.

2. Lumpy edges

Most memory foam and latex toppers are a little smaller than the mattress, so it's uncomfortable to sit or sleep near the edges especially when the topper is thick.

Overview Of Different Types Of Toppers

Memory Foam Topper

  • Pros: widely available in many varieties • significantly improve comfort
  • Cos: initial odor • sleeping hot especially for thicher models
  • Price Range: $40 to $270
  • Read detailed Memory Foam Topper Review.

Latex Topper

  • Pros: many varieties available • can make a mattress softer or firmer
  • Cos: often expensive • initial odor possible
  • Price Range: $130 to $700

Feather Topper

  • Pros: significantly soften a firm mattress • lightweight
  • Cos: feathers poking through the cover may cause pain • cannot be washed with water
  • Price Range: $50 to $400

Fiber Topper

  • Pros: inadequate thickness for some people • limited durability
  • Cos: initial odor • sleeping hot especially for thicher models
  • Price Range: $40 to $120

Wool Pad-Topper

  • Pros: long lifespan • warm in winter and cool in summer
  • Cos: initial odor • need to be fluffed regularly
  • Price Range: $120 to $360

Ratings

Memory Foam Latex Feather Fiber Wool Pad
Price
4
1
8
8
1
Conforming ability
9
7
2
2
3
Durability
6
8
5
2
8
Thickness Options
9
7
4
1
4
Motion Isolation
8
4
1
1
1
Easy To Move On
1
4
7
8
8
No Noise
9
9
2
4
8
No Sleeping Hot
2
3
8
4
6
No Initial Odor
1
6
4
8
4
No Lumpy
9
8
2
3
6
Sex Friendly
4
7
7
8
7
Washable
1
1
6
3
7
Appearance On Bed
8
8
4
4
6
Easy To Maintain
9
8
1
2
2
Availability
9
1
3
8
2
Easy To Lift, Handle
2
1
4
4
8